The short answer
Kittery is generally regarded as Maine’s oldest town. It was incorporated in 1647 and calls itself the oldest incorporated town in the state. Its neighbor York has an equally strong claim to being one of the earliest settled. York was established in the 1620s and in the early 1640s became Gorgeana, often described as the first chartered English city in America.
Which town counts as “oldest” depends on whether you mean first settled, first chartered or first incorporated. Earlier European settlement attempts in Maine didn’t survive.
Why “oldest” depends on the definition
Early colonial Maine was messy. Fishing camps, trading posts and small farming settlements appeared along the coast in the early 1600s. Many were abandoned, attacked or relocated, and town boundaries and names changed over time. So the different claims rest on different milestones:
- First European attempt at settlement (even if it failed)
- Earliest continuous settlement (people stayed)
- Earliest formal charter or incorporation (a legally recognized town)
The main contenders
Kittery
Kittery is at Maine’s southern tip, across the Piscataqua River from Portsmouth, New Hampshire. Settlers were active in the area from the 1620s, and Kittery was incorporated in 1647. That makes it the town most often named as Maine’s oldest incorporated town. Today it’s known for its outlet shopping, Fort McClary, and the nearby Portsmouth Naval Shipyard.
York
Just north of Kittery, York was settled in the 1620s under the name Agamenticus. In 1641/42, Sir Ferdinando Gorges had it chartered as the city of Gorgeana, which is widely cited as the first chartered English city in what became the United States. After Massachusetts took control, it was reorganized as the town of York in 1652. York’s historic district, the Old York Gaol and Cape Neddick (“Nubble”) Light make it a popular stop.
Saco and Biddeford
English explorer Richard Vines and his party are recorded as wintering near the mouth of the Saco River around 1616–1617, at what’s now Biddeford Pool. More permanent settlement followed in the 1630s. Biddeford and Saco both point to this early history.
Pemaquid (Bristol)
The Pemaquid peninsula, in today’s town of Bristol, was an important fishing and trading post from the 1620s. The Pemaquid Archeological Site is a National Historic Landmark, and Colonial Pemaquid preserves the remains of the early settlement and its forts.
Saint Croix Island and Popham: earlier but short-lived
Two famous early settlements predate all of the above but didn’t last:
- Saint Croix Island (1604): A French expedition led by Pierre Dugua, with Samuel de Champlain, spent a harsh winter on this island in the St. Croix River near Calais. Many settlers died, and the survivors moved on to Nova Scotia the next year. The site is now an international historic site.
- Popham Colony (1607): An English colony at the mouth of the Kennebec River, in what’s now Phippsburg, founded the same year as Jamestown. It was abandoned after about a year.
Because neither survived, they’re usually treated as the oldest settlement attempts rather than the oldest towns.
Visiting Maine’s oldest towns
Kittery and York are an easy pair on Maine’s southern coast. Both have walkable historic areas, beaches and good seafood, and they make a pleasant day out from a woodland stay in southern Maine. If you’re combining history with a night in the trees, our guide to the treehouse village in Maine covers clustered treehouse retreats and standout stays around the state. For the state’s signature tree, see what is the national tree of Maine?